by Sam Drew, Tiny and Joanna Letz/PNN
Note from the Editor:
As I lived through the personal experience of being raised as the child of a houseless, criminalized family in Amerikkka, arrested countless times for the sole act of being homeless and sleeping in our vehicle, evicted and displaced when landlords/poverty pimps no longer thought they needed to provide "affordable housing" witnessed my mama, a poor woman of color, harassed by CPS, welfare systems and the criminal (In) justice System, and finally, when I was incarcerated for these crimes of poverty, I began the journey to write my memoir; Criminal of Poverty; Growing up homeless in America , which chronicled my families story of three generations of poor women in Amerikkka and the subsequent launch and resistance of POOR Magazine, the organization. In 2005 I launched the welfareQUEENS, which was a play and media project focused on the ways that poor women and families are criminalized, and in 2006,when my book was finally published by City Lights Foundation, I began a year-long effort to raise awareness on the increasingly dangerous trend of the criminalization of poverty which crosses race, class, cultures and generations of folks. We held several panels, and town halls over the year. Last week much of our powerful work and scholarship culminated in a very powerful symposia sponsored by the Thelton Henderson Center for Social Justice held at UC Berkeley's Boalt Hall. The following are pieces of the symposia told to you by poverty
and race scholars Sam Drew, myself and one of the graduates of POOR's Race, Poverty and Media Justice Institute, Joanna Letz.
Day 1 at the Symposium
The welfareQUEENS breaking it down; a living, breathing, struggling group of mamaz
By Sam Drew
Day One began at 12:00 noon with a panel led by graduate students and fellows of the Institute for the Study of Social Change entitled: State Action, Community Perspectives, and the Moral Order focused on research these students had done on the criminalization of migrant workers. Sam Arrived at 1:30 for panel two.
As I sat stiff backed watching the welfareQUEENS entertain and inform the crowd at the "Whose Poverty? Whose Crime? Unlocking the Criminalization of Poverty" Symposium at the Thelton E. Henderson Center for Social Justice at the UC Berkeley's school of Law, I glanced at a middle aged African-American couple being entertained in an interactive call and response style that was 180 degrees in opposition to the detached and overly intellectual style of lecture- listen and recite, that usually occurs in the halls of academia.
Before the welfareQUEENS took control of the stage the audience had just finished intently listening to the panel, "Breaking it Down: The Root Causes of the Criminalization of Poverty." , which featured Paul Boden, Monique Morris Dr. James Garrett and was moderated by Steven Pitts
Paul Boden, is the co-founder and longtime director of the Coalition on Homelessness (COH), and works with the Western Regional Advocacy Project (WRAP). He explained how homelessness has its roots in early legal and political decisions. Boden said, "25 years of federal housing cuts have created more homelessness."
Monique Morris, Director of Research Center for Social Justice, talked about the differential treatment of certain communities. She said, "The root causes of criminalization are low wage jobs, educational factors like zero tolerance and a juvenile justice system that polices some communities differently."
Ms. Morris continued, "The Prison Industrial Complex is a function of slavery[and is] sustainable because it's financially profitable... the government is spending money not on building community resources, but on waging war on the poor [while] at the same time receiving financial gain from this war because institutions like the prison industrial complex are financially profitable."
Dr. James Garrett, Division Dean at the Peralta Colleges, spoke to societies attack on the black community and black youth. He said, "The drug war became the war on the black community which then became the war on black youth."
Near the end of the first day of the symposium, the welfareQUEENS added the warmth of a living, breathing, struggling group of mamaz dealing with poverty, welfare, racism, and disability. Their performance reached out and touched the crowd in a way a lecture or pie-chart never could. They were the folks who have lived their experiences and were re-defining research and living scholarship.
Day One ended with a lecture by Dorothy Roberts, a Professor of Law from Northwestern University School of Law who echoed much of the scholarship on the relationship to racism and criminalization presented by the welfareQUEENs with a historical overview beginning with the advent and use of paupers prisons in the early days of Amerikkka and Western Europe.
Day 2 at the Symposium
Trash, Dirt, Mess, Crazy, Stupid
Hygienic Metaphors and the complicit role of media and academia in Criminalizing/ targeting people in poverty
By Tiny
This Day began with the panel:Poor Crimes: How the United States Punishes People Living in Poverty and featured Carlos Mares, poverty and migrant scholar and founder of Founder, Lucha Unida del Jornalero breaking down the ways that migrant workers are consistently criminalized for the sole act of seeking work as well as Tirien Steinbach, Executive Director of East Bay Legal Community Law Center (EBLC) in Oakland who spoke on the ways in which people are criminalized for the sole act of sitting , standing, and walking while poor and the revolutionary ways that EBLC works to fight these citations for crimes of poverty as well as Elisa Della Piana from Lawyers Committe for Civil Rights who also fights for justice for class and raced-based crimes and broke down the ways in which she, a white housed female with a child isn't cited for sitting in public parks while folks who "look houseless" are cited and arrested around her.This powerful panel was moderated by UC berkeley Law professor Jeff Selbin.
The Trash, Mess, Dirt,Crazy, Stupid Media panel followed at 11:00am
As the power-point stalled on the screen for the waiting audience, listing all the labels my fellow poverty, race, disability, migrant and youth scholars and I have been called, I walked up the aisle of the Goldberg Room in Boalt Hall.
POOR Magazine scholars were lead organizers and co-sponsors of the symposia, an interesting process that included challenging academia's notions of scholarship head-on from the planning to the execution. Myself and Leroy Moore from POOR Magazine, Martin Reynolds of the Oakland Tribune and Susan Rasky of the Journalism School at UC Berkeley were panelists of the media panel. The power-point was the preview to my presentation which included a
condemnation of not only "the media" but of "academia". And I knew, without a doubt, that there was never a more important speech for me to deliver. This was it, my moment of glory, the final round in my Muhammad Ali Versus Joe Frazier bout.
POOR Magazine has been fighting for media justice, media access and about the very essence of this whole symposia since 1996 when POOR Magazine, the literary, visual arts, intentionally glossy magazine (and then later, the non-profit organization of the same name) was a dream in me and my poor mama's eyes, a chance for change in my formerly incarcerated, always poor, underground economy-involved family. A chance for people who have been and
continue to be oppressed, incarcerated and silenced for hundreds of years by systems, institutions and organizations that work to segregate, target and disempower our voices, to be finally heard.
I began...."There are many things this poverty scholar can teach you- but in reality, no more or less than any of the poverty scholars you see, or more than likely don't see, everyday. Homeless families, poor youth of color, migrant workers, panhandlers, sex workers; sitting, dwelling, camping, soliciting work, convening. I am them, they are me.
We are in a revolutionary struggle to not be lied about, incarcerated, mythologized, and misconstrued; to be truly heard and recognized for the deep scholarship we all hold; to survive while battling the looming jaws of poverty, the criminal injustice system, the police, the welfare system, and the gentrifying landlords.
But the one thing this poverty scholar must teach you is to re-think your notions of scholarship itself. Who is considered a great scholar? How is scholarship attained? How is greatness honored? And with what barometer do we measure this canon"
At POOR Magazine we have a radical concept of scholarship: who deserves it, how it is attained, and how it is used. This scholarship has a new canon, with new designations for greatness. Survival itself, through extreme poverty and crisis, houselessness, racism, disability, and welfare, to name a few, are what you need to qualify for poverty scholarship. Conversely, a person who is formally educated with a Master's Degree and no poverty scholarship would be considered inexperienced and therefore, should not be writing, lecturing, or legislating for and about communities in poverty. The formally understood "signs" of scholarship, such as writing, researching, critiquing, publishing, require inherent privilege. These signs afford people an ability to be heard and recognized."
I went on to explain the ways in which academia with its rigid notions of scholarship, research, data collection, and language domination acts to covertly and overtly, pathologize, separate, segregate, sort and label communities in poverty into categories and by so doing they are no longer at the table of power and decision-making.
From these roots I took people through a survey of corporate media's coverage of communities facing displacement, eviction, homelessness, profiling, border fascism, racism and Incarceration. Communities like the Bayview facing Lennar Corp and Its lies and poison and our fellow brother and sisters in the gulf's fight against massive racist displacement, the gang Injunction's Impact on youth of color, and on and on.
How POOR Magazine's Race, Poverty and Media Justice Institute teaches on "the Myth of objectivity" In media production, which just means that only certain people get spoken to, quoted and considered, I.e., the po-lice, the legislators, the so-called "experts".
Finally, the resistance of truth media, the true peoples' media like the SF Bayview, PoorNewsNetwork, El Tecolote, The Street Sheet, Street Spirit, The Block report, La Raza Chronicles and POOR Magazine on KPFA as well as how we as a people need to stop limiting our notions of what media is. Media is Hip Hop, graffiti, art, spoken word, flowetry, talk and story.
After my last word, the room was in a hush. After a couple of seconds people stood up and then an almost standing ovation filled the auditorium. For a moment, the power dynamic was challenged, the paradigm shifted, and the scholars were heard.
Day Three at the Symposium
Strategy Sessions and Solutions
"How do you invest people in interdependence?â€
By Joanna Letz
As I sat and listened intently to Tiny's presentation I looked around the room hoping everyone was holding onto each word as much as I was. The woman sitting next to me began a call and response as Tiny spoke, transforming the space from the stately, uprightness of academia into a fluid space of resistance. Time seemed to stop for a moment as Tiny finished her speech. No one had any words left to say.
As a person who comes from privilege I feel blessed to be a student in POOR Magazine's Race , poverty and Media Justice Institute's professional programs for college students and professionals which reinvents what it means to be educated and to educate. We are taught by poverty scholars educated in lived experiences how to really write, organize and do change-making media, policy and organizing.
At 12:30 the whole symposia broke out into lunchtime strategy sessions, focused on many forms of criminalization including vets, youth, mamaz and children, status crimes, media representations and homeless courts. Scholars like Willie Ratcliff joined Tiny in the media session, civil rights attorney and revolutionary legal advocate Osha Neuman and community legal scholar and PNN writer Marlon Crump dealt with status crimes, elder race and poverty scholars Bobby Brogan and Bruce Allison dealt with elders and welfareQueen Vivian Hain co-facilitated the mamaz session while Jennifer Friedenbach and welfareQUEEN and poverty scholar Jewnbug dealt the Housing strategies session.
One of the most powerful sessions co-facilitated by youth scholars in collaboration with educator Antwi Akom focused on youth. Their strategies included, "Education should be relevant to our communities (racially and ethnically), Develop and promote a Youth Bill of Rights, State youth, State activism: avenues for youths to express themselves and Be true to yourself and your culture."
The last panel, "Crossing the Poverty Line: Unlocking Solutions," addressed some of these strategies for resistance. Olis Simmons, Executive Director of Youth UpRising, spoke. Youth UpRising is a non-profit in East Oakland providing programming for youth between the ages of 13 to 23.Youth UpRising provides young people with job training, art classes, and access to health and wellness opportunities, including different holistic services such as massage and acupuncture.
Simmons said, "Criminalizing people because of our fear of who they are, often disinvesting them of the notions of citizenship…they no longer feel like the system is them.†Simmons' voice reverberated through the room. Her words echoed those of many of the other speakers.
Gary Blasi, Professor of Law at UCLA also spoke on the last panel. He reiterated the complete absurdity of criminalizing the poor, as he stated “An attempt to make the poor invisible, for no other reason than that they are poor. It is a crime to sit or sleep on public sidewalks…the most human of activities- a crime- sitting, eating, and breathing…A huge percentage of people in jails are homeless, many have some sort of disability. The reality is the current system is deeply invested in the criminalization of poverty."
He continued on to say, "To keep someone in jail a day costs $103, in supportive housing it costs $30 a day.. .the government is willing to spend that much money to keep the poor in jail the government has waged war on the poor...jails are the housing strategy for the poor."
The scholarship continued, as Olis Simmons said, "East Oakland is an incredibly vibrant community.. [and it is]..the most disenfranchised and criminalized population." There was an urgency in Simmons voice as she filled every second of her speech with information and insight about the youth of East Oakland. She said, "we are not a teen center.. .we are about developing and harnessing the power of young people." In a community where as she said, "it is illegal to drive your car around the lake more than one time.. and you can't park your car around the lake between 1 and 7am." Youth UpRising is doing work to reinvest and empower youth in their own lives.
Youth UpRising has 100 new young people every month, and has grown by 3200 youth in the last two years. Youth UpRising is also committed to coalition work, as Simmons put it, "relationships with people we don't want to be in relationships with." For example, the Oakland Police Department. But with whom Simmons said, "hopefully [we will] go beyond conferences.. and change the way the police do their work." Youth UpRising is creating for their own community, solutions to poverty, choices for young people, from young people, and that speak to young people.
Mari Villaluna, POOR's Indigenous Media Project Coordinator, was the last speaker of the day. Before she began her speech she asked Tiny, and Jewnbug from POOR to come to the podium. Mari presented offerings to both of them as a way of honoring their presence and influence in her life. As Tiny said, "if you think that this is not an act of resistance to the criminalization to poverty you are wrong." In just one act of honoring her elders the room was transformed into a space of resistance, honoring interdependency not individuation and working together as opposed to separate.
Mari went on to talk about some of POOR's projects. She said, "everybody already has a home, what many people don't have is a house, a shelter…POOR's Homefullness Project is a REAL solution to poverty and houselessness created by poverty, race, disability, youth, and indigenous scholars to actually change the position of poor families."
The site proposal will include: permanent housing units for homeless and formerly homeless families following a model of co-housing, a site for The F.A.M.I.L.Y. project and Artistikal Revolutionary Teaching (i.e., a social justice and arts based multi-generational, multi-cultural and multi-lingual school for families and children), a site for POOR Magazine's Race, Poverty, Arts and Media Justice Institute, and a site for The Justice Cafe; a multi-generational community arts and social justice eating and performance space.
Other POOR projects include: The Urban Indigenous Institute as a new inclusive model of education, the Po Mamaz column, and Voces De inmigrantes en resistencia. POOR Magazine also practices Family Council, a non-punitive, non poverty-pimp way of dealing with conflict in a grassroots organization.
Youth UpRising and POOR Magazine are just two organizations working towards creating spaces to resist poverty and criminalization. Community Action Network (CAN) is doing work in LA's Central City East region of Downtown, commonly known as Skid Row, which is home to over 11,000 homeless and extremely low-income people.
Coalition on Homelessness (COH) is also doing work to make visible and resist the criminalization of poverty. Paul Boden from COH addressed the last panel, "Lawyers for poor people! Front line attorneys. Legal defense…We're talking about it up here, and not defending it down here [on the ground].."
The system pathologizes poor people and people of color instead of doing what needs to be done; recognizing its own disease of criminalization and violence. The government is denying people their most human rights of shelter, wellness, and education. Poor people and people of color are dehumanized and labeled criminals as a way for the government to justify this war on poor people. For poor folks and houseless folks everyday is a "symposium" on the criminalization of poverty, everyday is an act of resistance.
As a person of privilege who is versed in the dominant language I feel I must make academia accountable, accountable to the way they play into the existing power structures and criminalization. One of the media strategies to make into reality is get POOR Magazine/POOR News Network, Street Sheet, Street Spirit, The Bayview Newspaper, on the required reading list for UCB's
Journalism School. As well as getting accreditation for internships at POOR Magazine, SF Bayview, and Street Sheet.
For people who come from privilege and wish to be an ally to the struggle of living poor in Amerikkka, organizations like POOR Magazine and Youth UpRising are always looking for people to do the nitty-gritty, day to day things along with looking for ways to fund POOR's many revolutionary projects. These organizations and the Poverty, Youth, Race, and Disability Scholars are resisting because to resist is a matter of life and death.
As Olis Simmons said, "How do you invest people in interdependence..[ the] quality and value of their lives is dependent on young people. Youth UpRising needs more resources and money...and hard-working people, to do the grind of the work.."
Links and Contacts for More Information--
Youth UpRising: www.youthuprising.org, 510-777-9909.
Community Action Network, LA, go to: www.cangress.org, 213-228-0024
Coalition on Homelessness: www.cohsf.org, 415-346-3740
Western Regional Advocacy Project: www.wraphome.org
Radio Free Georgia: WRFG.org
|